Small-business outsourcing research

What share of supplier invoices match the purchase order and receipt on first check?

A protocol for measuring how many supplier invoices agree with the purchase order and the receiving record on the first check.

What share of supplier invoices match the purchase order and receipt on first check?

Research question and scope

This protocol asks what share of supplier invoices agree with the purchase order and the receiving record on the first check. The unit is one invoice line, not one invoice and not one supplier. The study measures the share that match on quantity, price, and condition, the share that need a correction, and the share that are paid before a match is complete. It does not judge whether the supplier was at fault or whether the price was fair.

Set the scope to one shop, one purchasing process, and one payment rule. Record the order system, the receiving method, and the date the match rule took effect. If the shop changes its purchasing tool during the study, keep the original rule for invoices already in process and analyze later invoices separately. A new tool can change the match speed without changing the supplier behavior.

Define the population as every invoice line received during the window, including lines that were credited, corrected, or paid short. State any exclusion, such as a utility bill that has no purchase order, and apply it to every line. Test the definition on ten closed invoices before collection begins. The reader should be able to rebuild the population from the invoice register and the order list.

Definitions that make the measure reproducible

Define a match as an agreement between the invoiced quantity, the received quantity, and the ordered quantity on the same line. Define the price check as the invoiced unit price against the price on the purchase order, with any approved tolerance stated in advance. A match on quantity with an unapproved price difference is not a full match. Record the rule so a reviewer can repeat the judgment.

Define the first check as the first complete comparison made after the invoice arrived, not a later review triggered by a payment query. Record the time of the first check and the person who made it. Treat a corrected invoice as a new line with its own first check. A definition that counts a second review as the first check will overstate the result.

Evidence standard and data dictionary

For each invoice line, capture the invoice number, supplier, purchase order, item, quantity ordered, quantity received, quantity invoiced, unit price ordered, unit price invoiced, and line total. Add the receiving date, the check date, the checker, and the resolution. Keep the purchase order, the receiving note, and the invoice linked to the entry. Record any credit memo or corrected invoice by number.

Capture the reason for a mismatch when it is documented: a short shipment, a substituted item, a price change, a freight charge, or a duplicate line. Do not infer a reason from an empty field. Mark unknown reasons as unknown and report the count. A guessed reason hides the step that actually needs repair.

Sampling and collection

Collect every invoice line in the window rather than a sample, because the match rule applies to each line. If the shop runs several departments or suppliers, collect each separately and record the group. A combined rate can hide one department that pays before receiving. Report the number of lines and the value behind every percentage.

Draw the data from the order system and the invoice register, not from a spreadsheet kept after the fact. If either record is incomplete, say so and reduce the claim. Record the export date, the filters, and any line that could not be matched to a receiving note. A missing receiving note is itself a finding about the routine.

Analysis and reporting

Report the share of lines that match on the first check, the share that need a correction, and the share paid without a completed match. Show the median and range of days from invoice receipt to first check. Present the results by supplier, department, and invoice value. Use the same denominator for every rate.

Separate a mismatch caused by a supplier from one caused by the shop. A short shipment is a supplier issue, while a missing receiving record is a shop issue. Report both because they lead to different fixes. A shop may accept a supplier error but should not accept a match that never happened.

Limits of the evidence

The invoice and receiving records can show what was compared, but they cannot show whether the goods performed as expected. A match is not a quality test. The protocol also cannot capture a delivery that was received and invoiced with no paper record at all. State that limitation before presenting the rate.

A small shop may have too few invoice lines to support a stable trend. Describe the line count and the supplier mix instead of ranking staff. Do not compare a shop that orders weekly with one that orders daily. Report the match rule and the tolerance beside the rate.

What to change

Give the result to the owner and the purchasing lead and ask them to choose one observable change. The change might be a receiving note required before payment, a price tolerance agreed with the supplier, a named match owner, or a weekly exception review. Record the owner, the effective date, and the measure that will show whether the change worked. Repeat the protocol with the same definitions.

If the first-check rate rises but credit memos also rise, the shop may be matching faster while accepting more bad lines. If both fall but payment delays grow, the team may be holding invoices without a fix. Report the movements together before declaring success. Close the review when the owner accepts the finding and the next collection date is set.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Does a favorable sample prove the routine caused the result?

No. The design is observational and supports a bounded operating decision, not a universal causal claim.

What should an owner review first?

Start with high-consequence defects, missing denominators, exceptions, and cases that required the owner to reconstruct the evidence.

Related research