Small-business outsourcing research

What share of supplier backorders reach the customer with a written substitution approval?

A protocol for measuring how many backordered items are offered as a substitute only after the price and customer consent are recorded.

What share of supplier backorders reach the customer with a written substitution approval?

Research question and scope

This protocol asks what share of supplier backorders reach the customer with a written substitution approval. The unit is one backordered order line, not one order and not one customer. The study measures the share with a recorded substitute, an approved price difference, and an explicit customer reply. It does not judge whether the substitute was a better product or whether the supplier was at fault for the delay.

Set the scope to one shop, one purchasing process, and one substitution rule. Record the rule version, the approval levels, and the date the rule took effect. If the shop changes its order system during the window, keep the original rule for orders already open and analyze later orders separately. A new system can change the speed of approval without changing the underlying behavior.

Definitions that make the measure reproducible

Define a backorder as an order line the supplier has acknowledged but cannot ship by the promised date. Define a substitution as a different item number offered in place of the original line. Define written approval as a recorded customer reply plus a named shop approver before the substitute ships. A phone call summarized as okay is not a written approval under this definition.

Define the denominator as every backordered line that became eligible for a substitution during the window. Exclude lines where no substitute existed and record that count separately. Treat a partial shipment as a separate line with its own outcome. The reader should be able to rebuild the denominator from the order register and the supplier messages.

Evidence standard and data dictionary

For each backordered line, capture the order number, customer, original item, quantity, promised date, supplier message, substitute item, price difference, approver, customer reply, and ship date. Attach the customer message and the supplier confirmation to the entry. Record whether the substitute was new, refurbished, or a display unit. Keep the original and substitute prices visible so the margin can be checked.

Record the reason the substitution was offered, such as a missed deadline, a discontinued item, or a supplier stockout. Do not infer the reason from an empty field. Mark unknown reasons as unknown and report the count. A guessed reason hides whether the shop needs a better supplier or a better customer conversation.

Sampling and collection

Collect every backordered line in the window rather than a sample, because the substitution rule applies to each line. If the shop runs several departments or suppliers, collect each separately and record the group. Report the number of lines and the value behind every percentage. A combined rate can hide one department that routinely upgrades customers for free.

Draw the data from the order register and the supplier messages, not from a spreadsheet rebuilt after the fact. If either record is incomplete, say so and reduce the claim. Record the export date, the filters, and any line that could not be matched to a customer reply. A missing reply is itself a finding about the approval routine.

Analysis and reporting

Report the share of backordered lines with a written substitution approval, the share offered without approval, and the share never offered a substitute. Show the median days from the supplier delay notice to the customer message. Present the results by supplier, item category, and order value. Use the same denominator for every rate.

Separate a shop that chose not to offer a substitute from one that had no substitute available. Report both because they lead to different fixes. A shop may accept a supplier stockout but should not accept a substitute that ships without consent. Report the price difference direction so the reader can see whether customers paid more or less.

Limits of the evidence

The order records can show what was offered and approved, but they cannot show whether the customer understood the trade-off. A recorded yes is not proof of a good conversation. The protocol also cannot capture a substitution arranged verbally at the counter with no record at all. State that limitation before presenting the rate.

A small shop may have too few backorders to support a stable trend. Describe the line count and the supplier mix instead of ranking staff. Do not compare a shop that orders weekly with one that orders daily. Report the substitution rule and the approval threshold beside the rate.

What to change

Give the result to the owner and the purchasing lead and ask them to choose one observable change. The change might be a required customer reply before shipment, a price-difference approval limit, a substitute quality check, or a weekly backorder review. Record the owner, the effective date, and the measure that will show whether the change worked. Repeat the protocol with the same definitions.

If the written-approval rate rises but customer complaints also rise, the shop may be documenting a conversation that is still confusing. If both fall but cancellations grow, the team may be withholding substitutes that customers would have accepted. Report the movements together before declaring success. Close the review when the owner accepts the finding and the next collection date is set.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Does a favorable sample prove the routine caused the result?

No. The design is observational and supports a bounded operating decision, not a universal causal claim.

What should an owner review first?

Start with high-consequence defects, missing denominators, exceptions, and cases that required the owner to reconstruct the evidence.

Related research